A big part of my struggles in life has been to escape the concern with trivialities.
I pulled together a bunch of my pictures to send to my family. I realized with dismay that most of my pictures show me dressed in sleeveless shirts, tank tops, bikinis, cropped pants, and other “immodest” attire. I sent some pictures anyway and asked my sister to censor me as necessary when showing the pictures to my parents.
And I realized yet again how heartsick I am at all this brouhaha over bare arms. Jesus fucking Christ. The Muslim world in general and my family more immediately apparently don’t have any problems bigger than the amount of skin I routinely bare without ANY consequences to my health, safety, happiness or career.
Of course my family has bigger problems but all of them take a backseat to the the immorality because of which violence against women is necessary.
It’s disheartening.
The sad fact is that trivialities control the lives of people who don’t know how to put things in common-sense perspective. What matters is not what seems to matter; what matters is what a society sick with religion has drummed into you. There are occasional outbreaks of rationality where my parents might realize that our temporal well-being and happiness is what really counts, but then the overconcern with a strangely skewed morality takes over. It gets transmitted as muddled messages. Parents care about a daughter’s education and career but just can’t bring themselves to give it the same urgent importance as the education and career of a son.
My parents can sometimes actually sound progressive. They didn’t want to “marry me off.” They appreciated my intelligence and wanted me to get higher education. But when I graduated high school, there were no plans in place for me. The situation wasn’t critical as it was for my brother. The whole household was afire with the need to send my brother to college — without that, nothing in his future could be assured of going well. Me? Not so much. I was smarter and more ambitious but it hardly mattered.
Hypocritical reassurances would be given me when I spoke vaguely of going to this university or that, in this country or that. Sure, we’ll send you. When I did more concrete research and laid down what I would need from my parents to actually continue my education, the response was… resistance. All the old prejudices against letting a mere woman roam free in the world without oversight and restraints. Of course I couldn’t go to Dubai, was I crazy? And who would look after me, pray? Of course I couldn’t go to America, did I know how expensive that was going to be? And who would watch over me, anyway?
No matter that my brother had gone to both Dubai and the United States before me. Ah, but he was a man! Able to look after himself in the big bad world, you see.
What was puzzling at the time (and enraging) was that my parents could pretend with the best of them that such woman-limiting thoughts were not in their heads. They never let on that they would flat out refuse to let me continue my education unless I proposed something which appeased their prejudices. They also didn’t make any effort to actually promote the cause of my education. It was all me, I was on my own.
I ended up proposing Pakistan, which met with resistance as well. But still, they were reassured that there would be a phalanx of relatives watching my every move and scandal-mongering. Of course, the stupid twits would’ve been better off if the whole Pakistani universe I moved in hadn’t known everything I did that didn’t quite fall under the “Islamic and Proper” banner, but they made the mistake of assuming I was a normal Muslim girl who would behave however her elders and betters wanted her to behave. They thought I would have the normal amount of shame and restraint that they believed must have been bred into me from a guilt-ridden childhood.
Too bad for them that they were wrong.
Pakistan was simply not an option for my brother. It wasn’t good enough for education purposes. For me of course, Pakistan was plenty good enough.
So they paid through the nose for my brother’s American education for seven long years.
My sister has graduated high school but she’s reliving what I went through after my graduation. No plans in place for her, no higher education in sight.
My brother, even after his expensive education, wasn’t able to get an appropriate job and is working as a security guard and his income still needs to be supplemented by my dad.
Yeah, you read that right — my 28 year old brother who got an American education at great expense, is living in America — the land of opportunity — and unable to entirely support himself. He’s mooching off my dad, who has single-handedly slaved all his life to scrape together a living for his family.
My sister is not getting an education because she has a vagina and oh my god, whatever are we going to do about that!
Because obviously, it’s more important to keep her arms covered and her pussy protected from unauthorized cocks than to actually get her equipped to be independent and successful in her life.
Muslims will never progress until they stop thinking their chief way of protecting their traditions and culture and families is to guard every vagina in sight with a paranoid and rather ridiculous fervor, which includes the necessity for violence.
Meanwhile, I’M the big disappointment, the kid who destroyed everything.
All I did was say, fuck this shit — I’m going to live my life. It’s all I could’ve done. For this, for keeping my nose clean, being independent and successful (I’m directly competitive with kids my age who grew up in America and got expensive American educations — I’m even ahead a few years, both in income and employment), I’m judged (negatively) by my family, including my brother and my sister.
I could’ve achieved this differently, they say. I could’ve asked nicely instead of snatching what I wanted and “destroying the family.”
ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?!!
It’s hard to believe sometimes that my brother and sister share the same parents as I do. They honestly believe I could’ve asked nicely to marry an infidel, move to the United States and live my life independently and MY PARENTS WOULD HAVE CHEERFULLY AGREED!
Christ.
I know why it is that they have such a different perception. I knew my parents wouldn’t support me because I’d tried the ‘nice’ tack and it had failed. I also knew the limits of my parents’ tolerance because I was the only kid who really tested them by “acting out.” I refused to wear hijab and watched my dad get closer than he’s ever been to hitting me. I insisted on going out on walks alone and expressed my desire to socialize with friends — only to be forbidden on pain of endless haranguing from my mother.
The fights I had with my mother! The arguments I had with my dad! Neither of my siblings were that troublesome — nowhere close. Both mostly did as they were told, while kidding themselves that that’s what they really wanted.
Maybe that IS what they really wanted.
But the fact remains that I knew what my parents were willing to give me and the list did not include my freedom. Period. There really wasn’t much else I could do but simply snatch my freedom and leave, and consequences be damned.
As I said to my sister yesterday when she accused me of destroying the family, it was either destroy the family or let them destroy me. And unfortunately, I’m just not cut out to be a slave to trivialities.
Filed under: Feminism, Islam/Religion








i can’t imagine how horrible it must be for you, to be cut off from your family for the most part, with random communication that looks like it’s full of criticism anyway.
i find it so shocking that all the “unconditional love” bullshit that we grew up believing in is exactly that…bullshit.
i “acted out” as well but always within limits because i didn’t want to “destroy the family”. at close to 30 though, i look back and see so many different paths that i could have taken and wonder what life would’ve been like, if i had had the balls. now though, i keep encouraging my siblings to not worry about the parents – one is in love with a non-muslim and one is with a shia (my parents are sunni). the eldest, who is divorced, has moved back home to pursue her dream of becoming an actress and a model after years of being told that it was a terrible idea (primarily because of the whole “what would people say” crap).
i think my parents are finally coming to grips with the idea that the human beings that we are is more important that what we wear and what we do in our personal time. it took way too much time and i think you did the right thing by not sacrificing your youth and feeding them bits of your true self in smaller, easier to digest bites.
you’ve obviously done fabulously well and you should be proud of yourself. your family SHOULD love you unconditionally and the inability to do so is THEIR failure, not yours. you’re a fantastic, independent, intelligent girl and it’s a pity that they can’t see that and be proud of whatever role they played in producing you and making you who you are.
your sister just sounds young, sheltered and naive. and she’s just regurgitating what your parents have been telling her (about you destroying the family). it’s their own pride, stubbornness and sexism that destroyed the family, not you. so don’t buy into that bullshit.
great post btw…oh and i keep meaning to tell you: i absolutely love your blog, it’s the only one i check on a regular basis!
(sorry, bit of a tangent here)
i really don’t think religious people should have kids unless they’re ready to accept that the kid may turn out to be completely different from them. i have no idea why parents think that their children will automatically accept the religions and cultural values shoved down their throats…they’re giving birth to live, thinking, human beings…not robots.
it always bugs me that abortion is more difficult or against the law, while no one gives a shit or thinks twice about popping out a child (wanted or unwanted) and then treating it whatever way they like. they need to regulate parenting far more than abortions.
ugh…sometimes, i really hate the world we live in!
I’m sorry your sister isn’t able to see your perspective, especially when it would provide a helpful one for her.
I don’t usually advocate senseless violence, unless it’s in the ring, but if I ever meet this Maged Thabet al-Kholidy, I’m going to kick his ass.
The hardest thing for parents seems to be letting their children go. In my field, we call it “differentiate.” What it really means is trusting in yourself enough to know that the lessons you’ve imparted will serve your child well.
It’s sad that your parents don’t get to see you the way we get to see even just this little corner of your life. Because I think that if they gave themselves a chance, they’d be proud.
too sad that your childhood was like that of any other child yet you defied all the obligations of a child. I guess that then being an apostate is a punishment of you in my humble opinion.
Good Luck.
for you*
and hey, whats up with the “pussy-ness.”Comment moderation? lol.
Aposticillin: Does Apostate go to your website and act like a dick? No? Then act like a man and have some common empathy, you prick.
Apostate,
Off topic for bit, I was struck by your description of how different you are to your siblings. May i be impolite and ask if you are a middle child ?.
Not that i’m trying psychoanalysis over the internet (maybe just a little) and i’m aware of the stereotypical middle-child but i’ve noticed this is particularly evident with south asian families, not sure what it is in our culture that causes this.
Maybe the enforced and mandatory respect for ’seniors’ in our culture is what gets it started
Of course, being a man (and from a less restrictive religious background) i can only imagine your experience growing up but we all have to fight the good fight in our own way!!
take care
Hey, thanks for the kind words and support, y’all (excepting Aposticillin, whatever the hell his problem is).
Midnight Toker– yes, isn’t it obvious I’m the middle child? After all, I list everyone’s ages right there.
Yes, I’m the middle child. I don’t think that has a whole lot to do with my development though — I know lots of middle children of my background who aren’t noticeably different from their siblings.
Ohmigod. Your blog is undoubtedly bigger than mine, but I’m linking to you anyway (Blogroll Amnesty Day and all that). If for no other reason than to hear someone rant about all the shit that I would love to rant about (but don’t on my blog). Not to mention all the assholes from Karachi who find me when they do a Googlesearch on “16 yars old sex,” yaar.
So do me a favour and link to me. I don’t have photos of Benazir in a miniskirt (and I wouldn’t post them if I did), but I do blog on women’s rights and domestic violence and world issues and feminism and the absolutely sucky political issues that are plaguing the world and … oh, fuckit, come see for yourself.
La Casa de Los Gatos.
James,
it’s useless. Muslim men, like our friend “aposticillin” (very witty indeed) advocating sexism and fundamentalist “values” because they are “obligations” never feel any empathy with women or, for that matter, infidels — they are told from early childhood that both are evil. That’s why there is not a single muslim relief organisation in the world that reaches out to non-muslims, and that’s why I don’t consider any traditional muslim capable of something like real, heartfelt compassion for fellow human beings.
Apostate,
I admire your courage. As soon as they read this, the members of your family will be even more enraged. But you have been and still are right — if that’s a bit of a consolation…
Hey there — I’m also a Pakistani woman who has dealt with similar issues, but it seems my situation was much less extreme (one of the things that worked in my favour was that I have no brothers — I’m the oldest of three sisters). One thing I do want to say is that you are absolutely not alone. There are definitely other strong women from Pakistan going through the same issues, dealing with the same problems, and trying to live with integrity and grace. So I hope this might (at least briefly) temper your sense of alienation.
In my own journey though I have found the need to psychologically detach from the family completely — it has taken some time but it has happened, and it has actually improved my relationship with them. I just felt I was ready to let bygones be bygones and move on, without being constantly resentful toward them. I know the religiosity and the sexism and all the prejudices are absolutely insane, but I realized that the constant anger I was holding within myself was just making everything worse for everyone, most of all for me.
Btw I’m gay and have a girlfriend, and my parents are completely in denial of this and don’t even want to speak about it. It has bothered me a lot and still bothers me to an extent, but with time I am trying to learn to respect their limitations. Given their upbringing (my mother is actually from an abusive home; my mother’s father used to hit her mother), it is very difficult for them to change. Those early years are formative; we have some really amazing data now from neuroscience showing that the earliest attachments really impact how the brain develops.
Part of the whole problem is that human beings are born neurologically incomplete. The brain keeps developing for quite a long time, and human beings are utterly helpless for the first ten years or so of their lives. So if during that time, one’s needs aren’t met in a really fulfilling and complete way, one is bound to come out of it with emotional wounding and various neuroses. We all have these neuroses; the difference is just a matter of degree. The problem with parents is that they have this way of reminding you of precisely those times when you were completely helpless and at their mercy. That’s where all the anxiety comes from. But for both their sake and our own, we’ve got to find our own way and deal with the anxiety of individuation.
I guess, to sum up: you sound like a very courageous person and I respect your choices and find the story of your journey really inspiring. But one thing that I would suggest (humbly — and you can reject this thought if you want) is that it might be helpful to just work on letting go of the past and trying to see why your parents are as limited as they are in their vision and perspective. I found that when I realized that behind all the madness they were actually much more terrified than me, my empathy for them really increased — but before this was possible I had to psychologically detach and stop attributing mythical amounts of power to them in my head (it is really all a huge head-game). Meditation also really helped me stop doing this — i.e. attributing so much power to them over me.
Not sure if anything I’ve written was useful — I might be coming at this from a totally different angle — but in any event, good luck on the journey, and once again, you are most definitely NOT alone.
Ned, thank you for your thoughtful words.
If I sound angry, if I sound like I resent them, it’s because they are now doing to my sister what they did to me. The anger is on her behalf. I am beyond any place where they could reach out to hurt me. They try, but it doesn’t really reach me any more.
I’ve always had tons of empathy and sympathy for them, especially my mother. If anything, I feel more pity for them than anything else. If anything bugs me, it’s that they can’t pity me. We have all suffered, but I suffer for them, and they suffer for them. That irks me, but I understand why they are the way they are. My compass of comprehension is simply broader than theirs, and that’s not their fault.
The anger is less on my behalf than for my sister, in whom I naturally see a repetition of my benighted life. I would do anything to change things for her, but not unless she wants me to.
Again, thanks for your words and good luck on your journey.
ThePoliticalCat, you have been added. My husband (the Barefoot Bum) linked to you a little while ago and I didn’t realize you were desi. :)
Welcome to the blog.
Hey there — yeah I can understand how you feel about your sister.
I guess I got lucky because I have no brothers, and all three of us — my sisters and I — are extremely close, have always stood up for each other, and share the same basic values. Because of our persistent rebelliousness, our parents have basically been forced to evolve to some extent. I recently saw some social psychology papers that showed that the gender composition among siblings has a huge impact on the sort of cognitive schema that parents and families impose on their children. Needless to say, if you’re in an all-girls household, life is substantially easier and there’s going to be much less internalized sexism in that situation.
The situation w.r.t. your sister is sad, I really can’t imagine what that would be like since both of my sisters are so independent. But you’re right, you can’t help anyone who isn’t willing to help themselves. It’s painful to watch others asking for so much trouble, but I guess we have to respect the choices of others. The closest thing I can think of from my own experience is a cousin I have who is about the same age as my kid sister and who has two brothers. Because she has brothers, both her parents and her brothers feminize her no end (and not in a good way). She’s not allowed to do anything, the brothers monitor all her conversations with both girls and boys, and so on. By contrast my youngest sister, who is the same age, is a drummer in a rock band (in Islamabad, no less), plays on a soccer team, and is a very clear-headed kid. We’ve tried to knock some sense into our cousin but it can be so painful to tear oneself out of those chains. We often cling to our prisons so tightly.
I’ve been going through your blog and it’s quite amazing, everything you’ve accomplished — immigrating, working, studying, etc. I’m in New York right now myself, studying psychology, and although I’ve had my share of breakdowns and what-not, financially things are okay for me because I got a scholarship. Plus, for all their flaws, my parents have always been big on education — they always wanted their daughters to go for higher studies. So it’s really remarkable that you’ve achieved all you have.
I hope you don’t feel any guilt at all about disobeying the family. Guilt is a terrible thing. I forget which psychologist said this but I once read someone who had written that guilt is a real flight from integrity, the epitome of “divided we fall”. There is a difference between guilt and healthy shame. People who are neurotically guilt-ridden are constantly wasting their own energy on their guilt and inner warfare, and that’s precisely why they are the easiest to exploit and control.
Ned, thanks for the kind comments.
No, I don’t feel a whole lot of guilt. Sadness, yes, that I was forced to hurt my parents in a way I would’ve liked to avoid, but ultimately, the responsibility for them feeling the way they do is theirs and I’m not convinced I did anything wrong. I couldn’t have done anything differently.
The gender composition of a family might have something to do with how things pan out; on the other hand, my brother never controlled anything I did. I’ve always been headstrong, and always managed to get my way, and not in a subtle way either. My brother is a wimpy guy, to put it mildly. It’s my parents’ sexism that ultimately decided things happen the way they did.
I’m glad you’re free and you and your sisters have been rebellious and strong in your visions for yourself. That’s great to hear.
Hey hon,
I am glad that you’re in touch with your sister. And you’re brave to attempt what you’ve done. I don’t even bother with my brother and his wife, as you know I have a million issues with them. I find it ironic though, how the ones who stand up for what’s right, may get kicked around for a while, but in the end hopefully what’s correct prevails….
My sister in law planned a huge vacation and at the last minute lost her passport… Snicker…
Lots of love,
S
Apostate, thanks so much.
I’m completely blown away with your kickass, and I do mean kickass, blog. It’s great to hear other South Asian female voices on the issue of the fucked-up culture and its self-destructive take on half its population. I notice religion takes a backseat to culture in terms of oppression – Hindus are just as busy bashing women as Muslims, and let’s not leave desi Christians out of the love, either.
ned, it must really chap the family chapatis thinking about the gay kid, and think about it they do almost constantly (personal experience speaking here). Nothing like hearing your loving parents rant about how their son should only get AIDS and die for the crime of being gay.
thepoliticalcat, all South Asian families are not the same. And you don’t think that gaybashing doesn’t happen in non-south asian families? I’d like to introduce you to some homeless young queer people i know…